Web Review
Many kids know about both mitosis and meiosis, but few know
how to tell the difference between the two.
To me, the book never clearly illustated
how meiosis was for gametes and mitosis was for somatic cells. I mean, I knew, but did the book ever truly tell
me that? The answer to that question is no. So I set out to find some websites
that did.
NOVA
Online How Cells Divide: Mitosis vs Meiosis
This site was the best.
Great animations, universal lauguage - geared at
everyone, unversity pages don't often do that - and
very easy to understand. They showed the two processes side by side, no
difficulties in comparing them at all. The flash was incredible, very smooth. I
have nothing negative to say about this site, except for the fact that slower
computers may have a harder time of it. It was a much better resource than the
book was, I highly recommend it either as a extended
source or even your primary one. Amazing site, it was my favorite, if you
couldn't tell. Five stars out of five stars, excellent, excelllent.
Mitosis vs Meiosis
I
wasn't too impressed with site. There were no animations, simply pictures that
were confusing if you hadn't really delved into the subject. The
wording - great, but only if you had a clue when you first went to the site.
Not a good primary learing tool at all
, in my opinion. It was a good site, of course, very informative, but
really, not a good page for for your average ninth
grader. It even confused me, and I thought I had a pretty good handle on the
whole thing. Don't get me wrong, it was nice but it annoyed me for some odd
reason. Probably because I felt incredibly stupid as I left. If you were
confused when you left the book, I wouldn't go here anytime soon. Two stars -
only because I'm a nice person.
Dr. Chromo's School
This
was okay. It was useful only if you knew what was going on by having gone to
his other pages as well. The division of
the site was also confusing, as while there was a separating line it didn't
seem obvious to me. I had to search for
it. The information was correct, it'd be horrible if
we had to corrcect the poor doctor. I also thought
the pictures were pretty good. It just didn't stike
me as an oustanding site. However, since I didn't
hate it as much as the page before this it shall recieve
a higher score. Three stars.
My
reviews attempt to criticize things that would have universal appeal, like
bright colors and pretty animations, whether the
information was true and how easy it was to understand. The only site that
truly benefited me was the Nova site I listed, it was true enrichment. The
other two weren't that great, simply better than the book. Which, if you think
about it, isn't that hard.
biblio for project
nova online www. pbs.org/wgbh/nova/miracle/ divi_flash.html
ameiois www. stanford.edu/groups/urchin/ameiosis.htm
mitosis vs
meiosis www.vcbio.science.ru.nl/en/virtuallessons/cellcycle/mitomeio
dr chromos School www.rothamstead.bbsrc.ac.uk/notebook/courses/guide/meiogif.htm
.